Providing The Latest News With Opinions

Antioch to Fill “Vacant Council Seat” with Application Process


Kudos go out to the Antioch City Council who chose last night to make an appointment for the empty City Council seat via application process versus a straight appointment based off election results.  Mayor Wade Harper, and councilmembers Mary Rocha, Monica Wilson and Gary Agopian voted unanimously Tuesday to accept applications for the remaining two years of the seat left open after Harper was sworn in as mayor.

Applicants now have a week to get their applications in along with 30 signatures and financial statements.  On December 18, applicants will be allowed to make a brief public statement no greater than 3-minutes.  This is open to any Antioch resident.

According to the Contra Costa Times, former Mayors James Davis and Donald Freitas will be applying while city council candidates Walter Ruehlig and Noel Pinto are undecided.

While some will say this is “2008 again” and because the council chose to bypass James Davis like they did Arne Simonsen. I disagree.

One does not pick someone just because they finished next in line during an election. An appointment is done off of merits, beliefs, the dynamics of the council, and the direction one wants to go.  It’s not a popularity contest in an appointment process, its about choosing a direction a council wants to go. After all, its the council voters put in place to make this decision.

Some claim the council needed to listen to the “will of the people” which is very misguided use of the term.  To truly listen to the will of the people, Antioch would have to go the route of a costly special election. Besides, who gets to decide who “the people are” when not everyone gets to vote.  If one really wants to break this down, lets break it down. During the most recent election, residents were able to vote for two people (Rocha and Wilson won). The “will of the people” did not choose Davis.  So now people want to use this “will of the people” and throw out the majority of Antioch who didn’t vote for Davis to appoint him.

A hypothetical special election would also not guarantee Davis would even win–Freitas is also no lock.  Throw these two into a new field and maybe residents want another candidate now that the Rocha and Wilson votes are back in play.  Who knows what would happen.

That is why the council that the “will of the people” actually voted in get to make this decision on the peoples behalf.  This is a great thing for Antioch as it opens the door for those who did not run for the seat to have an opportunity to apply.   The naysayers will continue to chirp, but the Council made the right call.

Burk Byline

By Michael Burkholder


Tagged as: , , , , , ,

7 Responses »

  1. Burke, you are wrong on this. Davis should have been appointed just like Simonsen should have been appointed in 2008. Doesn’t take a genius to figure out Harper, Wilson and Rocha will pick the appointee.

  2. I think they made the right call, but this is a perfect way to stack the council if they are not watched.

  3. They have made up their minds this is just to look better. It will be Manuel from the Panning Commission. Absolutely a stacked council. All votes will be 4-0 for the next 2 years except for piddling little one that don’t count. AND Harper will have an office in City Hall.

  4. Burk, you knocked this one out of the park as Agopian doesn’t apparently get it in claiming the election should be the bench. When you remove Wilson and Rocha’s votes, of course Davis is next in line. Put those votes back in, Davis loses again. Nice counter to that idiot Agopian.

    • Gary Agopian was not wrong in opinion because some people prefer that it have gone to the third place finisher while some preferred an election. Agopians preference simply would not be my preference and that is fine. I wouldn’t call him an idiot either for encouraging one of three options made available in the staff report. It’s simply a difference of opinion.

  5. It will be interesting to see how stacked the deck will be for the police getting 3@50 and union support. Antioch makes me sick!

  6. 3@50 will pass on the 27th at the spcial meeting.

    Now, Mr Manuel was sitting there ready to be sworn in and was in shock when it turned out this way. I’m sure Mr Harper has smoothed his feathers and assured him he would still get it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: